Quality Assurance Checklist for Literature Review

Core Problem Quality

  • Specific population and location defined
  • Problem stated without causes or solutions
  • Observable and measurable
  • Represents urgent and important issue
  • Connects to your organization’s mission

Root Causes Quality

  • Answer “why” the problem exists
  • Go 2-3 levels deep with sub-causes
  • Mix of evidence-based (E) and assumptions (A)
  • Cover different cause categories
  • Are potentially addressable through interventions

Effects Quality

  • Show realistic consequences of the problem
  • Include both short and long-term impacts
  • Consider individual, community, and system levels
  • Are observable and specific
  • Demonstrate why solving the problem matters

Research Quality

  • Sources documented and credible
  • Evidence separated from assumptions
  • Gaps and uncertainties identified
  • Stakeholder validation questions prepared
  • Ready for community engagement